Big-upping the fat girls

Top 10 Reasons Why The BMI Is Bogus

July 7th, 2009

From NPR:

1. The person who dreamed up the BMI said explicitly that it could not and should not be used to indicate the level of fatness in an individual.

The BMI was introduced in the early 19th century by a Belgian named Lambert Adolphe Jacques Quetelet. He was a mathematician, not a physician. He produced the formula to give a quick and easy way to measure the degree of obesity of the general population to assist the government in allocating resources. In other words, it is a 200-year-old hack.

Thanks to Een for the heads up!

Posted by mo pie

Filed under: Health, Science, Tidbit

You might also like

  1. Blah Blah Leptin. Where's Jen Wade?
  2. What Beautiful Looks Like
  3. 10 Reasons The Biggest Loser Bugs Weetabix

7 Responses to Top 10 Reasons Why The BMI Is Bogus

  1. Bethany, on July 7th, 2009 at 5:05 pm Said:

    Interesting article. I really agree that we need to rethink a lot of the categories and boxes we love to shove people into based on all sorts of bodily factors and measurements — maybe it allows us to classify people easily, and come up with absurd averages for what “normal” is, but it’s just so misleading on so many levels.

    The last line was odd, in terms of the rest of the article, calling obesity “one of the leading causes of poor health and premature death.” While I’m not totally sure this is untrue in general, I think it’s at least worth noting that (as all HAES advocates will also assert), it is not a necessary connection in all cases.

  2. Porky, on July 7th, 2009 at 5:24 pm Said:

    Hey there! Just wanted to let you know that I’m linking you now cause I love your posts. I look forward to reading more in the future!

  3. Rachel, on July 7th, 2009 at 5:33 pm Said:

    “Mathematical snake oil…” Love it! Thanks for the link.

  4. Alyssa, on July 7th, 2009 at 11:05 pm Said:

    I KNEW it!!!!!!!!

  5. Addish, on July 8th, 2009 at 12:38 am Said:

    Oh this just reminded me! I saw in the paper somewhere even saying that the bmi was full of crap. I just can’t remember exactly where I saw it. Darn.

  6. abby, on July 8th, 2009 at 6:34 am Said:

    SO TRUE! it’s crap! I haven’t read the whole article so maybe it’s mentioned, but I HIGHLY recommend reading ‘Big Fat Lies’. BRILLIANT! I literally said out loud “WHAT?!?!?!’ about 10 times just reading the first chapter. It’s all about debunking all the myths and crap out there surrounding BMI, health, size, etc. READ IT!

  7. J.B., on July 8th, 2009 at 4:55 pm Said:

    In order for my BMI to be “Normal” I’d have to lose 100% of my body fat and 3 lbs of lean body mass.. I’d be dead. It’s a crock.

Subscribe to the comments for this post (RSS)

« Magic Imaginary Weight Loss Surgery Is Magic!
Beth Ditto's Got a Collection! »

RSS button Entries RSS

RSS button Comments RSS

Email us

Look around
  • What's the Big Fat Deal?
  • Introduce yourself
  • How do I love myself? And the follow up.
  • Our Facebook group
  • BFD greatest hits
  • 10 Ways to be a Body Positivity Advocate
  • Our pet fish
  • Press and media
We are...
Image of Mo Pie Image of Weetabix Image of Jenfu
Find it
Meta
+ Click to display
  • Log in
  • Entries RSS
  • Comments RSS
  •  
  • Google Reader or Homepage
  • del.icio.us 43 Folders
  • Add to My Yahoo!
  • Subscribe with Bloglines
  • Subscribe in NewsGator Online
  • Furl 43 Folders
  • Add to Technorati Favorites!
  • Add to netvibes
  • Health Blogs - Blog Top Sites
  • Pop Culture Blogs -  Blog Catalog Blog Directory
  • Blogging Fusion Blog Directory
  • I fight fat-hate!
  • B-List Blogger
  • Bloggapedia, Blog Directory - Find It!
  • As Seen on Delightfulblogs.com
  • Blogarama - The Blog Directory
  • Top HealthCare Sites
  • + Click to hide
Your comments
  • Babs: So sorry to hear that you are moving to Facebook. I’m one of those “dinosaurs” who refused to...
  • Trish: I’m a heavier girl, and throughout my pregnancy so far I’ve not thought too much about looking...
  • Rhonwyyn: Hi Mali, So sorry you’re feeling this way. I was never very skinny, but I learned to hate my body as...
  • Jody: I just got this cute Disney Nerds bag at Disneyland this January. It was only $20 and the strap is super long....
  • Courtney: I found one at H&M. Can’t wear a damn thing from that store except their bags, and it was under...
Recent entries
  • New BFD Page on Facebook
  • Recommend A Crossbody Bag
  • It Happened To Me: I Read xoJane.com
  • Actor Gains 50 Pounds, Becomes "Much Funnier"?
  • Nordstrom Rack Fall Outfit Extravaganza
  • Say Yes To The Dress: Big Bliss
Notes from the Fatosphere
Most Popular Categories
  • Advertising Advocacy America Ferrera American Idol Art Ask BFD Beth Ditto BFD Classic BFDudes Biggest Loser BlogHer08 Books Britney Spears Carnie Wilson Celebrities Cold Hard Cash Comics Courtney Love Dance Your Ass Off Diet Talk Diet Talk Warning Drop Dead Diva Eating Disorders Exercise Fashion Fatism Fat Positive Fat Suits Feel Good Friday Feminism Food Gabby Sidibe Glee Gossip Guest Post Gwyneth Paltrow Hairspray Health Huge Humor International Jenfu Jennifer Aniston Jennifer Hudson Jennifer Love Hewitt Jessica Simpson Kate Winslet Keira Knightley Kelly Clarkson Kids Kirstie Alley Links Magazines Media Meta Mike & Molly Mo'Nique Mommyblog More To Love Movies Music Nikki Blonsky NSFW Old Navy Old Timey Oprah Personal Photoshop Politics Project Runway Queen Latifah Question Race & Ethnicity Renee Zelwegger Review Ricki Lake Ricky Gervais Science Sex & Romance Star Jones Theater The Office Tidbit TV Tyra Banks Uncategorized Video Weetabix Weight Loss WLS Work

Twitter
[aktt_tweets count="5"]
Most Comments
  • Nordstrom Rack Fall Outfit Extravaganza (232)
  • How Do Strangers Treat You? (134)
  • "The Beautiful People Are The Skinny People" (103)
  • "You Do Not See Fat People In Concentration Camps" (100)
  • Are You Insecure About Your Height? (97)
  • Big Fat Ad (91)
Archives
Powered by WordPress & WPDesigner :: Design by Pattycake Designs & modified by Make My Blog Pretty :: Logo by Evan Carothers